Week 45: Anti-Muslim and Anti-Islamic Discrimination
November is Islamophobia Awareness Month, run by the Muslim Engagement and Development (MEND) non-profit in the United Kingdom. Kumi Now would like to bring the message of Islamophobia Awareness Month to a world audience.
The constant slings and arrows inherent in the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territory have all the markings of anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic discrimination. While not all Palestinians are Muslims, and the overwhelming majority of Muslims have never engaged in any kind of violence, the overarching view in Western media of Palestinians as Muslim terrorists has done nothing to build global support for the anti-colonial struggles of the Palestinians in a way that the world supported the struggles in Ireland, India, and South Africa. Here’s what you need to know about Islamophobia and what you can do so that together we can rise up.
Topic: Anti-Muslim and Anti-Islamic Discrimination
Let us begin by defining anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic discrimination, or islamophobia. We use as our guide Council on American-Islamic Relations’ (CAIR) online document “Islamophobia 101.” Here is how CAIR defines islamophobia:
In short, Islamophobia is anti–Muslim racism.
At length, Islamophobia is a fear, hatred, or prejudice toward Islam and Muslims that results in a pattern of discrimination and oppression. Islamophobia creates a distorted understanding of Islam and Muslims by transforming the global and historical faith tradition of Islam, along with the rich history of cultural and ethnic diversity of its adherents, into a set of stereotyped characteristics most often reducible to themes of violence, civilizational subversion, and fundamental otherness. Islamophobia must also be understood as a system of both religious and racial animosity that is perpetuated by private citizens as well as cultural and political structures.
What does it look like?
The perpetrators of anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic discrimination can either be individual citizens or government or military officials, or Islamophobia can be embedded in company, organizational, or governmental structures and policies.
At the individual level, this dicrimination consists of violence against Muslims or perceived Muslims in the form of physical intimidation and assault and verbal stereotyping, intimidation, abuse, and hate speech. And it extends to the vandalizing of individual property and the property of Islamic institutions including mosques, Islamic schools, and Muslim cemeteries.
At an institutional level it includes discrimination in employment (where Muslims are faced with unequal opportunities), discrimination in the provision of health services, exclusion from managerial positions and jobs of high responsibility, racial profiling by law enforcement, and exclusion from political and governmental posts. It can be seen in legislation and policy measures that overtly or covertly targets muslims at the exclusion of other religious or social groups. Finally, anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic discrimination also comprises prejudice in the media, literature, and everyday conversation.
Where does it occur?
Islamophobia is well documented in the United States, France, Denmark, Israel, and across Europe, but occurs in every country with a Muslim minority.
Where does it come from?
CAIR points to five sources of contemporary discrimination:
- Media representation: CAIR explains, “many media outlets overemphasizes negative coverage and news pertaining to Muslims and Islam leading to an exaggerated sense of threat, and consequently fear and hate.” They reference a Washington Post study that found that domestic attacks conducted by Muslims (only 12% of the total) received, on average, 449% more media coverage than attacks committed by others.
- Political rhetoric: The second source is politicians who “play on people’s emotions and exploit their fear to actively instigate Islamophobia when it serves their own political interests.”
- Violent extremism: The vile actions of groups such as ISIS continues to color perceptions of Islam and all Muslims. It should be noted that the actions of extremists who call themselves Christians do not color the perceptions of other Christians in the same manner, suggesting a connection to other factors.
- American foreign policy: CAIR also points to American foreign policy, which has a strong influence on American citizens and governments and individuals around the world, particularly in Europe.
- U.S. Islamophobia Network: Finally, CAIR argues, “An influential, multi-million dollar network of groups and individuals in the U.S. who falsely cast Islam and Muslims as a malevolent existential threat, and work actively to promote prejudice, discrimination, and oppression towards the faith and its practitioners.”
How is it changing?
Sharp increases in such hate crimes seem to have begun in the early 2000s. This rise could be attributed to the growing number of anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic institutions and the normalization of hostility towards Islam. And the ease with which information travels in the age of Twitter takes an act from its local context to the international arena, thus creating an impression that there is a universal anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic ethos and emboldening other would-be Islamophobes.
Over a decade on, and in light of continuing immigration from North Africa and the Middle East and the rise of right wing parties across the EU, the situation is only worse. In 2018 the Foundation for Political, Economic and Social Research (SETA) released their “European Islamophobia Report” for 2017. In it, they provide a big picture of discrimination across Europe, and include a number of concerning statistics, including:
- In Germany, 100 attacks occurred on mosques, 908 attacks targeted German Muslims, and there were 1,906 criminal attacks on refugees (5.2 attacks per day).
- In Spain, 546 attacks took place against Muslims.
- And in Austria 256 Islamophobic incidents were documented.
In England and Wales the Home Office reported that in 2018 “hate crime has rocketed by 40 percent in a year across England and Wales, as the number of offenses recorded hits a record high” while “more than half of religiously-motivated attacks in 2017–18 were directed at Muslims and the next most commonly targeted group was Jewish people.” Overall, the number of hate crimes “more than double the total five years ago—and all categories saw a rise.”
Islamophobia and the Palestinian Question
A consistently anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic propaganda is being used against the Palestinian people to prevent them from ending the Israeli occupation.
When it comes to the question of Palestine, there are three major misconceptions that get in the way of real support for Palestine and the end to occupation:
- The Palestinian people are Muslims: It is true most Palestinians are Muslim. However, many Palestinians are Christians, Druze, Bahai, and Samaritans. The point, however, is not to separate non-Muslim Palestinians from their Muslim neighbors. Instead, it is to point out that all Palestinians are lumped together under a western stereotype of ‘Arab’ or ‘Muslim’ that has no basis in reality. Nearly a quarter of all humans identify as Muslim, yet many Westerners continue to judge all Arabs and Muslims based on the actions of religious and cultural extremists.
- The clash of civilizations is history and is inevitable for the present and future: The relationship with Islam and the Western world is defined through the wars and campaigns among a Christian dominated west and the East controlled by Islam. The relationship between Islam and other religions was not always bad in the East. Christians and Jews enjoyed many years of peace in the East.
- A religious conflict: It is true religion plays a large part in the conflict, however it’s a struggle for land and human rights. In the past century the Palestinian people have revolted against all forms of occupation, whether it was Ottoman, British or Israeli.
When looked at through the lens of anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic stereotypes, Professor Mustafa Abu Sway argues, “Only enemies of peace would continue to be against an end to the Israeli occupation. To be against the establishment of a Palestinian state could be described as an essentially Islamophobic position.”
Throughout the week, Kumi Now will publish essays and stories from different organizations further exploring the rise and effects of anti-Muslim and anti-Islamic discrimination and highlighting what they are doing to stop it.
Story: Leanne Gale, Jewish woman observing Israeli security guards harassing a woman in a niqab
“What was the problem?” I asked her in Arabic.
She looked at me in shock. That often happens when I speak Arabic.
“I’m Jewish, I just happen to speak a bit of Arabic. Are you okay?”
“Yes, yes I’m okay. It was just a security check, it’s okay.”
“Yes, it’s because I’m religious, I wear the niqab. I get stopped every time.” Then, she switched to almost flawless English. “I am only coming into the West of the city because I have a daughter with disabilities, and I come here to arrange aspects of her care. Otherwise, I would not come here. This harassment is so unnecessary.”
What are you supposed to say to that? I couldn’t give her advice or fix the problem; she is a Palestinian woman and she will be harassed by male Israeli soldiers, security guards, and police likely for the rest of her life.
“I’m sorry. I know that doesn’t help, but I’m Jewish and I’m sorry. I hope you have a good rest of your day.”
“Thank you, habibti, it’s okay, it’s not your fault.”
She was so calm, so powerful in her forceful conviction and relaxed demeanor. So often, we just assume that Muslim women in hijab or niqab must be submissive or meek. Not so.
By Leanne Gale. Originally published by Mondoweiss.
Opposing Islamophobia needs to be a worldwide action, so start at home. Do you know where the closest mosque or Islamic center is to your home? Have you been there? Or, conversely, have you ever brought a non-Muslim friend to your mosque or Islamic center?
Make it a point this week to reach out and make these connections:
- Visit a mosque (or invite a visitor).
- Attend a class, prayer, or celebration at a mosque.
- Have coffee with the imam or other leader and have an informal discussion of Islamophobia in your area.
Share the video of the poem (below) on social media, along with an explanation of how you are reaching out against Islamophobia. Encourage others to do likewise, and include a link to this page of the Kumi Now website along with the hashtags #Islamophobia, #KumiNow, and #Kumi44.
Literature: “This is Not a Humanizing Poem” by Suhaiymah Manzoor-Khan
This will not be a “Muslims are like us” poem.
I refuse to be respectable.
Instead love us when we’re lazy,
love us when we’re poor.
Love us when we aren’t athletes,
when we don’t bake cakes,
when we don’t offer our homes
or free taxi rides after the event.
When we’re wretched, suicidal, naked and contributing nothing. Love us then.
Because if you need me to prove my humanity,
I’m not the one that’s not human.
From “This is Not a Humanizing Poem” by Suhaiymah Manzoor-Khan. Suhaiymah is a Muslim woman poet from Pakistani heritage known for her writing, plays, and spoken-word. You can watch her performance here.